HSC Geography · Teaching presentation

13.2 Causes of Climate Change

Natural vs human · ruling out nature · the carbon cycle & greenhouse effect
Laptops down · copy the ✍️ notebook boxes as we go

What we're doing today ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Chapter 13.1 established what the data shows — the world is warming, fast. This lesson answers the harder question: why, and how scientists know the cause is us, not a natural cycle. That distinction — natural vs human forcing — is the backbone of the whole climate-change topic and of every extended response you'll write on it.

By the end you can:

  • separate natural from human causes of change;
  • rule out ice-age (Milankovitch) cycles & volcanoes;
  • explain how humans disrupt the carbon cycle;
  • distinguish the natural greenhouse effect from the enhanced one;
  • use the 800,000-year CO₂ record as decisive evidence.
Natural forcing — volcanoes
Human forcing — fossil fuels

Two kinds of cause ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Every explanation of climate change sorts into one of two buckets. Natural forcings have operated for billions of years and work slowly — over thousands to millions of years. Human (anthropogenic) forcings have been added only since the Industrial Revolution, and they act fast — in decades. The scientific skill in this topic is telling the two apart, and then showing why the recent warming can only be the human kind.

Natural

Orbital (Milankovitch) cycles, solar output, volcanic eruptions, ocean circulation. Slow — thousands to millions of years.

Human

Carbon-cycle disruption, fossil-fuel burning, deforestation, the enhanced greenhouse effect. Fast — the last ~250 years.

Recent warming is far too rapid to be natural — and it lines up exactly with industrialisation.
Natural cycles shaped the ice ages
Industry is the new, fast driver
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Comparing causes
Natural

Ruling out nature

Ice-age cycles ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Milankovitch cycles — slow, regular changes in Earth's orbit and axial tilt that alter how much solar radiation reaches each part of the planet — pacing the ice ages.

These orbital wobbles — Milankovitch cycles — play out over 10,000 to 100,000+ years, and have driven at least five major ice ages. Three overlapping cycles set the rhythm: eccentricity (the orbit's shape, ~100,000 yrs), obliquity (axial tilt, ~41,000 yrs) and precession (axial wobble, ~23,000 yrs).

But they are ruled out for today's warming for two reasons: the timing is wrong (on this clock Earth should be slowly cooling right now), and they act far too slowly to explain a change measured in decades. A natural cycle cannot turn on a dime — the current spike can.

Ice ages are the big natural driver
…but they are slow — today's change isn't
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Cause & consequence

Case study: Mount Pinatubo (1991)

~20 million tonnes of SO₂ → cooled Earth ~0.5°C for 1–2 years

When Mount Pinatubo erupted in the Philippines in June 1991 it injected about 20 million tonnes of sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere. The haze reflected sunlight and cooled the whole planet by roughly 0.5°C for one to two years.

This is the key point for the exam: large eruptions cause short-term cooling, not warming. And although volcanoes do emit CO₂, all the world's volcanoes together release far less than human fossil-fuel burning. Put in numbers: humans emit roughly 40 billion tonnes of CO₂ a year; every volcano on Earth combined manages barely 0.3–0.4 billion — about 100 times less.

Volcanoes cool the planet briefly — they can't explain a decades-long warming trend.
Ash & SO₂ reflect sunlight — cooling
Yet the long-term trend is warming
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Interpreting a case study
Human

The human fingerprint

Disrupting the carbon cycle ✍️ Copy into your notebook

ATMOSPHERE (CO₂) Plants (sink)photosynthesis Oceans (sink)absorb CO₂ HUMANS: fossil fuels+ deforestation (removes sinks)

Carbon constantly moves between the atmosphere, plants and the oceans — the land and sea act as carbon sinks that absorb roughly half of what is emitted. Humans unbalance this two ways at once: burning fossil fuels releases carbon locked away for millions of years, while deforestation removes the sinks that would soak it up. The result is a net rise in atmospheric CO₂, tracked live at Mauna Loa (NOAA) — the single biggest cause of modern warming.

The carbon numbers
  • Pre-industrial CO₂: ~280 ppm — stable for millennia.
  • Today: over 420 ppm, rising ~2–3 ppm every year.
  • Land & ocean sinks absorb only about half of emissions.
  • Fossil fuels: ~37 billion tonnes of CO₂ a year.
  • Deforestation adds ~10% of emissions & strips the sinks.
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Reading a systems diagram

The enhanced greenhouse effect ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Natural Enhanced (human) some heat escapes thicker GHG layer more heat trapped

The greenhouse effect itself is natural and essential: gases such as water vapour and CO₂ trap outgoing heat and keep Earth about 33°C warmer than it would otherwise be — without it the planet would be frozen. The problem is the human enhancement: extra CO₂, methane and nitrous oxide thicken that heat-trapping blanket, so more energy stays in the system and the surface warms. The IPCC's Sixth Assessment concludes this human enhancement is unequivocally the cause of observed warming.

The gases & the numbers
  • Natural greenhouse keeps Earth ~33°C warmer — essential.
  • CO₂ is up ~50% since 1850 (280 → 420+ ppm).
  • Methane traps ~80× more heat than CO₂ (over 20 yrs).
  • Plus nitrous oxide (N₂O) & water-vapour feedback.
  • Warming so far: ~1.2°C above pre-industrial.
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Explaining a mechanism
The clincher

800,000 years of CO₂

CO₂ is off the chart ✍️ Copy into your notebook

300 ppm — never exceeded in 800,000 yrs 300420pastnow >420

Air bubbles trapped in Antarctic ice preserve samples of the atmosphere going back 800,000 years. Across that entire record — through every ice-age cycle — CO₂ never once rose above about 300 ppm. Today it is over 420 ppm and climbing, tracked live on the Keeling Curve. On a geological timescale the rise is near-vertical, and it lines up precisely with industrialisation.

Why it's decisive
  • Today's CO₂ is outside the entire natural range of 800,000 years.
  • The spike aligns exactly with industrialisation (~1850 on).
  • It is read from ice cores — trapped bubbles of ancient air.
  • Natural cycles have never produced a rise this fast.
  • It rules out ‘it's just a natural cycle’ as an argument.
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Interpreting a long-record chart

Watch: the big picture ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Before you write, watch this short overview from National Geographic. It ties the whole causal chain together — greenhouse gases, the human activities that release them, and the consequences that follow — in one three-minute narrative. Treat it as a model of how to link cause to effect in a paragraph.

▶ Watch: Causes and Effects of Climate Change — National Geographic (click → opens on YouTube)

As you watch, note: (1) which greenhouse gases are named; (2) which human activities are identified as sources; (3) how each cause connects to a real-world effect.

📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Synthesising evidence

Sources & explore further ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Every claim in this lesson traces back to a primary source — a dataset, a measurement record or an assessment report. Use these to check the data yourself and to build a research task. Being able to name and cite a source is exactly what lifts a Band 5–6 response above a Band 3–4 one.

Primary source — original data or an official assessment, not someone's summary of it. Cite these, not a random blog.
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Referencing sources

Extended response ✍️ Copy into your notebook

“Explain how we know recent climate change is caused by humans rather than natural processes.”
Intro — define natural vs human causes; state your line.
Rule out nature — Milankovitch cycles too slow; volcanoes cool & emit little CO₂; solar output flat.
Human causes — carbon-cycle disruption + the enhanced greenhouse effect.
Clincher — the 800,000-year ice-core CO₂ record + the Keeling Curve.
Conclusion — the weight of evidence points clearly to humans.
Marks come from
  • Ruling out each natural cause explicitly, not just asserting.
  • Naming the mechanism — carbon cycle, enhanced greenhouse.
  • Using the 800,000-year evidence as the decider.
  • Citing a source (NOAA, Scripps, IPCC) for your data.
  • A clear, evidence-weighted conclusion.
📘 Syllabus: Human–Environment Interactions · climate change🧭 Skill: Extended response

Glossary recap ✍️ Copy into your notebook

Milankovitch cycles — slow orbital/tilt changes that pace the ice ages.
Carbon cycle — the movement of carbon between atmosphere, land & oceans.
Carbon sink — a store that absorbs more carbon than it releases (plants, oceans).
Greenhouse effect — greenhouse gases trapping outgoing heat — natural & essential.
Enhanced greenhouse effect — the human-caused increase in that trapping, which drives warming.
Sulphur dioxide (SO₂) — a volcanic gas that reflects sunlight, causing short-term cooling.
Ice core — a cylinder of ancient ice whose trapped air bubbles reveal past CO₂.
Anthropogenic — caused by human activity.
Attribution — the science of linking an observed change to a specific cause.
Next lesson

13.3 — Impacts of climate change

1 / 0